4/29/2020
E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly
disability claims.[34]
Hence, it has been held that if serious doubt exists on the company designated
physician’s declaration of the nature of a seaman’s injury, resort to prognosis of other
competent medical professionals should be made. In doing so, a seaman should be
given the opportunity to assert his claim after proving the nature of his injury. This
proof will in turn be used to determine the benefits rightfully accruing to him.[35]
Psoriasis comes from the Greek word “psora” which means itch. It is a common
disfiguring and stigmatising skin disease associated with profound impaired quality of
life.[36] People with psoriasis typically have sharply demarcated erythematous plaques
covered by silvery white scales, which most commonly appear on the elbows, knees,
scalp, umbilicus, and lumbar area.[37] Chronic plaque psoriasis (psoriasis vulgaris) is
the most common type of the disease which manifests thru plaques of varying degrees
of scaling, thickening and inflammation in the skin. The plaques are typically ovalshaped, of variable size and clearly distinct from adjacent normal skin.[38]
As a result of the chronic, incurable nature of psoriasis, associated morbidity is
significant. Patients in primary care and hospital settings have similar reductions in
quality of life specifically in the functional, psychological and social dimensions.
Symptoms specifically related to the skin (i.e., chronic itch, bleeding, scaling, nail
involvement), problems related to treatments (mess, odor, inconvenience, time),
arthritis, and the effect of living with a highly visible, disfiguring skin disease
(difficulties with relationships, difficulties with securing employment, and poor selfesteem) all contribute to morbidity. About one in four patients experience major
psychological distress, and the extent to which they feel socially stigmatised and
excluded is significant.[39]
Current available treatments for the disease are reasonably effective as short-term
therapy. Extended disease control is, however, difficult to achieve as the safety profile
of most therapeutic agents limit their long-term use. [40]
Until now, the exact cause of psoriasis remains a mystery. But several family studies
have provided compelling evidence of a genetic predisposition to psoriasis, although the
inheritance pattern is still unclear.[41] Other environmental factors such as climate
changes, physical trauma, infections of the upper respiratory tract,[42] drugs, and
stress may also trigger its onset or development.[43]
After a circumspect evaluation of the conflicting medical certifications of Drs. Alegre
and Fugoso, the Court finds that serious doubts pervade in the former. While both
doctors gave a brief description of psoriasis, it was only Dr. Fugoso who categorically
stated a factor that triggered the activity of the respondent’s disease – stress, drug or
alcohol intake, etc. Dr. Alegre immediately concluded that it is not work-related on the
basis merely of the absence of psoriasis in the schedule of compensable diseases in
Sections 32 and 32-A of the POEA-SEC. Dr. Alegre failed to consider the varied factors
the respondent could have been exposed to while on board the vessel. At best, his
certification was merely concerned with the examination of the respondent for purposes
elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/56025
8/13