5/28/2020 E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly [15] Id. at 42. [16] See id. at 35. See also rollo, p. 182. [17] Id. at 167. [18] Collective Bargaining Agreement between United Philippine Lines, Inc. and Associated Marine Officers & Seamen’s Union of the Philippines (AMUSOP). (See id. at 129-139.) [19] Dated June 13, 2008. Id. at 83-84. [20] See respondents’ Position Paper filed on October 8, 2008; id. at 85-98. [21] Id. at 88-89. [22] Id. at 93-95. [23] Id. at 95-96. [24] Id. at 165-176. Penned by Labor Arbiter Daisy G. Cauton-Barcelona. [25] Id. at 176. [26] Id. at 172. [27] Id. at 173-174. [28] Pertaining to the e-mail sent by Dr. Abaya to Atty. Florencio L. Aquino. (See CA rollo, p.104.) [29] Id. at 175. [30] See respondents’ Notice of Appeal with Memorandum on Appeal filed on March 6, 2009; id. at 177-208. [31] Rollo, pp. 34-40. [32] Id. at 38. [33] Id. at 38-39. [34] Id. at 39. elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/58338 14/18