Republic of the Philippines Supreme Court Manila     SECOND DIVISION     VARORIENT SHIPPING CO., INC., and.,d G.R. No. 161934 ARIA MARITIME CO., LTD.,       Present: Petitioners,     VELASCO, JR.,* J.,   NACHURA,** J., Acting   Chairperson, - versus - PERALTA,   MENDOZA, and     ** Designated as an additional member in lieu of Senior Associate Justice Antonio T. Carpio, per Special Order No. 897, dated September 28, 2010. **** Per Special Order No. 898, dated September 28, 2010.

Select target paragraph3