V. >> F ramework in Practice - Implementing and Monitoring Rights
>> Setting up human rights monitoring systems
C. S
etting up human rights monitoring systems
Human rights monitoring is not divorced from other
monitoring mechanisms such as those applied
by any international, national or subnational
administrative agency; monitoring, for instance,
agricultural production and food security, human
development, administration of justice, or even
project-level development outputs and impact.
A human rights monitoring system builds on existing
monitoring systems by bringing in the human rights
perspective through recognition of the stakeholders—
the rights holders and the duty bearers—and the kind
of information relevant to them in implementing and
enjoying human rights. This necessitates a certain
institutional arrangement for the collection and
analysis of information and a focus on specific
data that embody and reflect the realization of
human rights.
A good monitoring system requires a clear
distinction to be made between institutions with
administrative responsibility for implementing
programmes and providing information on them,
and institutions responsible for monitoring progress
in the implementation of the programmes. This
distinction between the generator of data and
their use by a monitoring mechanism is particularly
important for human rights assessments, because the
inherent conflict of interest between the two roles
could seriously compromise the accountability of the
duty bearers and the credibility of the process.
Human rights monitoring requires a focus on data
related to attainments and enjoyment of rights
for the most vulnerable and the marginalized
population groups. This is not in conflict with the
universality and inalienable nature of human rights.
A shift in focus from national or regional averages
to vulnerable groups, ideally going down to the
level of an individual, makes it possible to assess
the extent of discrimination or lack of equality or
even violation of rights of that individual, which is
a principal concern in monitoring the realization of
human rights. Moreover, the state of well-being of a
vulnerable and marginalized individual or population group can in itself be an indicator of the overall
well-being and enjoyment of human rights for the
entire population.26
This, however, does not mean that human rights
monitoring is only about disaggregated information.
As highlighted in this Guide, human rights monitoring
requires an appropriate set of indicators anchored in
human rights standards, based on population averages and on information pertaining to individual
cases, as tools to facilitate a credible assessment of
human rights implementation (see chap. II).
Recognizing and incorporating these elements in
monitoring systems strengthens them and makes
them more appropriate for human rights measurement and implementation. In setting up rights-based
monitoring and indicator systems at the country level,
or strengthening existing mechanisms to promote
and monitor the implementation of human rights,
one can identify, among others, the following steps.
26. See the discussion on statistical averages vis-à-vis information on individual cases in chap. I.
Human Rights Indicators
133
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents