III. Distribution of Benefits
xxx
C. Other Terminations
When the employment of an employee is terminated by the Company for a
reason other than one in A, without any misconduct on his part, a
percentage of the total amount credited to his account will be distributed to
him in accordance with the following.
Credited Service............Percentage
36 months..................50%
48 months..................75%
60 months..................100%
When the employment of an employee is terminated due to his poor
performance, misconduct, unavailability, etc., or if employee is not offered
re-engagement for similar reasons, no distribution of any portion of
employees account will ever be made to him (or his eligible survivor/s). A
determination of poor performance, misconduct and unavailability shall be
made by the Company. Miso
Misconduct shall include acts and offenses as defined in the Contract of
Enlistment and Company Manuals.
xxx15[15]
Petitioners claim that since both of them had rendered at least twenty (20) years, or 240
months, of faithful service to private respondents, they are entitled to receive 100% of
the total credited contributions, pursuant to the aforesaid provisions. Contrary to the
findings of public respondent, petitioners argue that they were not guilty of "poor
performance" for petitioner Millares, in fact, qualified for the Merit Pay Program 16[16] of
15[15]
Id., at 172.
16[16] Merit Pay Program Objective. - Eligible are Masters and Chief Engineers who are
permanent (and are not in Probationary Status anymore). However, not every eligible officer
receives Merit Pay. The philosophy underlying the Merit Pay Program is recognition of "extra
effort." With this philosophy in mind, an eligible officer who does what is expected in the
execution of his duties receives his normal pay. It is those Officers whose performance is above
"just what is expected" that are recognized for their extra effort. (underscoring supplied)