6/9/2020
E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly
that the execution of the Project would be under their joint management.[5]
The SOB required the contractors to submit (1) a performance bond of ID271,808/610
representing 5% of the total contract price and (2) an advance payment bond of
ID541,608/901 representing 10% of the advance payment to be released upon signing
of the contract.[6] To comply with these requirements, respondents 3-Plex and VPECI
applied for the issuance of a guarantee with petitioner Philguarantee, a government
financial institution empowered to issue guarantees for qualified Filipino contractors to
secure the performance of approved service contracts abroad.[7]
Petitioner Philguarantee approved respondents’ application.
Subsequently, letters of
guarantee[8] were issued by Philguarantee to the Rafidain Bank of Baghdad covering
100% of the performance and advance payment bonds, but they were not accepted by
SOB. What SOB required was a letter-guarantee from Rafidain Bank, the government
bank of Iraq. Rafidain Bank then issued a performance bond in favor of SOB on the
condition that another foreign bank, not Philguarantee, would issue a counterguarantee to cover its exposure. Al Ahli Bank of Kuwait was, therefore, engaged to
provide a counter-guarantee to Rafidain Bank, but it required a similar counterguarantee in its favor from the petitioner. Thus, three layers of guarantees had to be
arranged.[9]
Upon the application of respondents 3-Plex and VPECI, petitioner Philguarantee issued
in favor of Al Ahli Bank of Kuwait Letter of Guarantee No. 81-194-F [10] (Performance
Bond Guarantee) in the amount of ID271,808/610 and Letter of Guarantee No. 81-195F[11] (Advance Payment Guarantee) in the amount of ID541,608/901, both for a term
of eighteen months from 25 May 1981. These letters of guarantee were secured by (1)
a Deed of Undertaking[12] executed by respondents VPECI, Spouses Vicente P. Eusebio
and Soledad C. Eusebio, 3-Plex, and Spouses Eduardo E. Santos and Iluminada Santos;
and (2) a surety bond[13] issued by respondent First Integrated Bonding and Insurance
Company, Inc. (FIBICI). The Surety Bond was later amended on 23 June 1981 to
increase the amount of coverage from P6.4 million to P6.967 million and to change the
bank in whose favor the petitioner’s guarantee was issued, from Rafidain Bank to Al
Ahli Bank of Kuwait.[14]
On 11 June 1981, SOB and the joint venture VPECI and Ajyal executed the service
contract[15] for the construction of the Institute of Physical Therapy – Medical
Rehabilitation Center, Phase II, in Baghdad, Iraq, wherein the joint venture contractor
undertook to complete the Project within a period of 547 days or 18 months. Under
the Contract, the Joint Venture would supply manpower and materials, and SOB would
refund to the former 25% of the project cost in Iraqi Dinar and the 75% in US dollars
at the exchange rate of 1 Dinar to 3.37777 US Dollars.[16]
The construction, which was supposed to start on 2 June 1981, commenced only on the
last week of August 1981. Because of this delay and the slow progress of the
construction work due to some setbacks and difficulties, the Project was not completed
on 15 November 1982 as scheduled. But in October 1982, upon foreseeing the
elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/45413
2/17