Separate Concurring Opinion
15
G.R. No. 224469
future and their probable increase, and after distributing to
the natives what may be necessary for tillage and pasturage,
confirming them in what they now have and giving them
more if necessary, all the rest of said lands may remain free
and unencumbered for us to dispose of as we may wish.
We therefore order and command that all viceroys
and presidents of pretorial courts designate at such time as
shall to them seem most expedient, a suitable period within
which all possessors of tracts, farms, plantations, and
estates shall exhibit to them and to the court officers
appointed by them for this purpose, their title deeds thereto.
And those who are in possession by virtue of proper deeds
and receipts, or by virtue of just prescriptive right shall be
protected, and all the rest shall be restored to us to be
disposed of at our will." 68 (Citations omitted, emphasis in
the original)
Having exclusive dominion over the lands in the Philippines, the
Spanish government began issuing royal grants and concessions which
effectively distributed land rights to the Spaniards and loyal Spanish
subjects. This notwithstanding, the Law of the Indies, and the subsequent
laws enacted by the Spanish government, made it clear that the distribution
of land rights and interests should not impair the rights and interests of the
natives in their holdings. 69
The Spanish Government's intention to guarantee the rights of the
natives over their lands was reiterated and further clarified in the subsequent
Royal Decree of October 15, 1754, which stated that the native's "justified
long and continuous possession" qualified them for title to their cultivated
land. The Royal Decree considered as valid title the native's ancient
possession of their land, notwithstanding the possessor's failure to produce
title deeds over the land. 70
The Royal Cedula Circular of March 3, 1798 further expounded on
this matter and proclaimed that "the will of the 'Crown' as expressed in
various, instructions, royal edicts, orders and decrees, that the distribution of
land to conquistadores' discoverers, and settlers should never prejudice the
natives and their land-holdings." 71
Despite the apRarent deference of the Spanish Government to the
native's rights over their lands, subsequent laws, however, triggered their
68
69
70
71
J. Puno, Separate Opinion in Cruz v. Secretary of Natural Resources, 400 Phil. 932, 934-935 (2000)
[Per Curiam, En Banc].
Owen James Lynch, Jr., Native Title, Private Right and Tribal Land Law: An Introductory Survey, 57
PHIL. L. J. 268, 274 (I 982).
Id. at 274-275.
Id. at 275.