3/25/2021 E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly [1] Rollo, 72-73.1 [2] Ibid., 41-52.2 [3] First Division, composed of Commissioners Vicente S.E. Veloso, ponente; Rogelio I. Rayala, presiding commissioner; and Alberto R. Quimpo. [4] Rollo, 54-65. [5] Thirteenth Division, composed of Justices Omar U. Amin, ponente; Hector L. Hofilena, chairman; and Jose L. Sabio. [6] Rollo, 71-89. [7] Petitioners' Memorandum, 11. [8] Rollo, 49-51. [9] Ibid., 85-86. [10] Labor Code, Book IV, Title II, Chapter I, Article 167(u), (v). [11] Civil Code, Article 1370; Palmares v. Court of Appeals, 288 SCRA 422 (1998). [12] Cruz v. Court of Appeals, 293 SCRA 239 (1998). [13] Words and Phrases, Permanent Edition,"Designate," vol. 12, 415 (1954). Citing State v. Noah, 124 N.W. 1121, 1126, 20 N.D. 281; Colgrove v. U.S., C.A. Cal., 176 F.2d 614, 617; Lankford v. Pope, 57 S.E.2d 538, 540, 206 Ga. 430; Thrailkill v. Smith, 138 N.E. 532, 534, 106 Ohio St. 1; Hall v. Cotton, 180 S.W. 779, 781, 167 Ky. 464, L.R.A.1916C, 1124; State ex rel. Rocky Mountain Bell Tel. Co. v. City of Red Lodge, 83 P. 642, 643, 33 Mont. 345, quoting and adopting definition in Webst.Int.Dict.; Lowry v. Davis, 70 N.W. 190, 101 Iowa, 236, 239; Jewel Tea Co. v. City of Geneva, 291 N.W. 664, 669, 137 Neb. 768; St. Louis Police Relief Ass'n v. Tierney, 91 S.W. 968, 974, 116 Mo.App. 447. [14] Rollo, 49-50, 86. [15] Petitioners' Memorandum, 12-13. [16] Records, 154. [17] Rollo, 51. [18] Ibid., 86-87. https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/50003 15/16