Figure 2. Process for the drafting
and finalization of scorecard
indicators
CSO partners agreed to discuss the
regional tool with other organizations within
their respective countries, and to pilot-test
the tool on cases of investments in rural
communities. Through such processes, and
taking into consideration the local country
contexts, several country scorecard tools were
developed. Partners from the six countries also
provided their inputs to refine the regional tool,
for the scorecard to be generally applicable to
varied settings in the wider Asian region.
The results of this initiative were
presented to CSOs, officials from NHRIs, and
intergovernmental organizations, during a
regional conference in Bangkok co-organized
by ANGOC, LWA, ILC Asia, United Nations
Development Programme, and the UN Office
of the High Commissioner on Human Rights,
on 15-16 November 2018.
The drafting and consultation process are
mapped out in Figure 2.
Scope and limitations
The scorecard assesses investments’ basic respect for human rights but
provides particular focus on evaluating whether these investments are able to
respect concerned communities’ land and resource tenure rights. In its present
formulation, the tool developed may only be applied to private rural investments.
The scorecard might have to be modified to be applicable to investments in
urban areas. A separate or expanded version of the present scorecard would
have to be developed if it is to cover State projects or investments.
Moreover, the tool may only be used to assess investors conducting
exploration activities, or investments that have just begun operations. During
these initial stages, potential long-term damage may still be avoided. Applying
this scorecard may help communities to decide whether the investment is
beneficial for them, or whether it is a bane that should no longer be allowed to
remain.
86
Upholding Land Rights amidst the Land Rush
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents