115
Forestry investments involve the use of forest resources that are considered
public lands under Philippine law. There were seven cases that cover 115,100
hectares, all of which involved encroachment on ancestral domains.
Stakeholder responses to land conflicts
Responses to conflict can be categorized into four: (1) yielding; (2) violence;
(3) peaceful claim-making; and, (4) conflict resolution. Yielding involves
stakeholders surrendering their claims and allowing their opponent’s goals
and interests to prevail. It was found that many rural poor communities were
forced to yield to the interests of investors and migrants because of their poor
adaptive capacity to situations of conflict and sheer fear in the midst of the
vast resources available to their opponents. Of the 14 cases wherein rural poor
communities yielded to the demands of investors, five cases resulted in the
community members seeking employment in the enterprise that displaced
them due to extreme poverty.
For the rural poor under threat, the risks involved in claim-making often
outweigh the potential benefits. In many instances, they are forced to yield
initially to the interest of their opponents. Later, they pursue other courses of
action when opportunities to assert their claims become available. Investors
only yielded to rural poor communities in four cases when the government
enforced decisions in favor of the communities.
One particularly maladaptive form of response to conflict is engaging in
acts of violence. Violence is often caused by poor access to justice, when
stakeholders (particularly the rural poor), do not have the means to pursue
their claims through peaceful means. When a conflict turns violent, damage
to lives, health, livelihood, and people’s sense of security and normalcy are
sustained by both direct and indirect stakeholders. However, the brunt of
the damage is usually borne by those who have the least capacity to engage
in violence. Violent responses can come in the form of acts of revenge, the
installation of barriers to prevent access to land/resources under contention;
and the mobilization of armed groups. Violence only further escalates conflict
and breeds a vicious cycle of retaliation.
Land Conflicts and Land Rights Defenders in the Philippines
Infrastructure investments pose the greatest threat of displacement. These
accounted for 64 percent of total households threatened with eviction and
displacement/damage to livelihoods (28,010 households). Such potentially
ruinous infrastructures consist of the construction of dams intended to provide
hydro-electric power and water supply to cities in exchange for displacement
of rural communities, mostly consisting of ICCs/IPs living adjacent to urban
centers.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents