6/5/2020
E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly
Indubitably, the failure of respondents' company-designated doctor/s to
declare complainant's fitness for work reasonably infers a scheme to evade
full payment of disability benefits to the complainant, by merely declaring
complainant partially disabled with a Grade 6 Impediment assessment.
Verily, it was undisputed that despite continuous medical treatment,
complainant continue[s] to suffer his ailment and the same remained
uncured, until [the] present, which rendered him unable to work and earn
income for his family.
As a result therefore of the injury he sustained while on board the vessel
"ELSE MAERSK DENMARK", complainant was unable to work for more than
120 days that resulted in the impairment of his earning capacity.
xxxx
Hence, this Office rules that notwithstanding the medical assessment of
respondents' company-designated doctors, jurisprudence dictates that
complainant be entitled to permanent total disability benefits by reason of
his continued medical condition that rendered him incapacitated for work for
more than 120 days from the date he was medically repatriated x x x to the
Philippines.
On the other hand, for lack of particulars, complainant's claim for medical
expenses and for non-payment of wages, overtime pay, vacation leave and
sick leave pay, the same could not be reasonably granted under the
circumstances for lack of factual basis with which to make an appropriate
award.
xxxx
Similarly, for lack of particulars as to complainant's claim for damages, the
same could not be reasonably granted under the circumstances for lack of
factual basis with which to make an appropriate award.
xxxx
WHEREFORE, premises considered, judgment is hereby rendered ordering
the respondents, jointly and severally, to pay the complainant total disability
benefits corresponding the [sic] schedule of rates provided for under the
CBA between the AMOSUP and respondent manning agency.
Respondents are likewise ordered to pay respondents [sic] attorney's fees
equivalent to ten (10%) percent of the total judgment award.
The computation unit of this Office is hereby directed to compute the
monetary award of the complainant which forms part of this decision.[46]
elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/61305
9/25