Republic of the Philippines Supreme Court Manila     SECOND DIVISION     INTERORIENT MARITIME G.R. No. 181112 ENTERPRISES, INC.,   INTERORIENT ENTERPRISES, INC., and LIBERIA AND DOROTHEA Present: SHIPPING CO., LTD.,   CARPIO, J. Petitioners,     - versus     Chairperson, NACHURA, PERALTA, ABAD, and MENDOZA, JJ.  

Select target paragraph3