SECOND DIVISION     EDGARDO M. PANGANIBAN , Petitioner,   G.R. No. 187032         Present:       CARPIO, J., Chairperson, - versus   NACHURA, LEONARDO-DE CASTRO,*   PERALTA, and   MENDOZA, JJ.     TARA TRADING SHIPMANAGEMENT INC. AND SHINLINE SDN BHD, Respondents.   Promulgated:   October 18, 2010   ** Designated as an additional member in lieu of Justice Roberto A. Abad, per Special Order No. 905 dated October 5, 2010.

Select target paragraph3