9/15/21, 8:01 PM
E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly
When meting out compensations according to POEA Ru1es, any entitlements
according to the Danish Industrial Injuries Act should be set of. The set off is
based on a conversion of any running benefits into a lumpsum according to
specific rules laid down by the Danish Minister of Social Affairs.[38]
The CBA provides that any amount awarded under the Danish Industrial Injuries Act
shall be subtracted from the compensation respondent is found to be entitled under the
POEA-SEC. Any deficiency would be the amount payable to respondent. Necessarily, a
prior ruling in accordance with the Danish Industrial Injuries Act is necessary in order
to determine whether such deficiency exists.
With this determination, it must be noted there is no more hindrance in the resolution
of this case as the NBII has already rendered its Decision[39] granting respondent: a)
8% disability benefits in the amount of USD9,596.39 or DKK64,408.00,[40] b) loss of
earning capacity equivalent to 75% for which the respondent will receive a monthly
compensation in the amount of DKK6,268.00 from January 28, 2015 until June 10,
2038, when the respondent reaches 68 years old.[41] There is no more any practical
value in dismissing the case on the ground of prematurity merely because respondent
instituted this action during the pendency of the proceedings before the NBII. It is
more judicious to resolve the instant case to finally put an end to this controversy.
The NBII Decision was brought to the attention by petitioner on September 24, 2015
through a Manifestation filed before the CA.[42] The same NBII Decision was considered
and recognized by the CA in rendering its herein assailed Decision. Notably, respondent
made no comment or objection to the introduction of the NBII Decision before the CA.
Likewise, petitioner did not assail or repudiate the said NBII Decision in its petition
before this Court. Similarly, no objection was made by respondent with respect to
petitioner's submission that he had already received a total of DKK98,661.00 or
USD14,566.78 – representing disability benefits of DKK64,408.00 or USD9,596.39
which respondent received on May 26, 2015, and DKK34,253.00 or USD4970.38, back
payment for loss of earning capacity until February 29, 2016. These payments were
supported by statements issued by the Danske Bank that the amounts have been
credited to respondent's accounts at the Bank of the Philippine Islands, Ayala Avenue
Branch.[43] Respondent similarly does not dispute this fact.
The NBII Decision, of itself, is presumptive evidence of the rights as between the
parties.[44] Coupled with its partial execution in the form of payment to respondent of
disability benefits, there remains to be no genuine issue in this case but the execution
of its remaining disposition vis-a-vis the provisions of POEA SEC.[45]
Pursuant to the NBII Decision, Mr. Frederick Nielsen of the Danish Shipowner Accident
Insurance Association affirmed that respondent is entitled to receive DKK2,860.00 by
way of monthly compensation for loss earning capacity until he reaches the age of 68
years.[46] Respondent having been born on June 10, 1969, is therefore entitled to
receive this monthly compensation until June 9, 2038. Respondent is therefore entitled
to a total amount of DKK764,411.00 or USD121,601.43[47] as compensation for loss
of earning capacity, computed as follows:
https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/67062
6/10