04/02/2020 E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly T-3;” (d) The portion rubber stamped by the Office of the Executive Secretary at the back thereof showing receipt by Masli A. Quilaman of NCIP-QC on March 15, 2010 as Exhibit “2-T-4;” xxxx D) The Appointment Paper of FRANCISCA BESTOYONG- ROSQUITA dated March 5, 2010 as Exhibit “2-W” for the respondents; 9. A) The Transmittal Letter pertinent to the appointment of IRMA A. VILLANUEVA as Administrator for Visayas, Board of Administrators, Cooperative Development Authority, Department of Finance dated March 8, 2010 as Exhibit “2-X” for the respondents; (a) The portion rubber stamped by the Office of the Executive Secretary at the back thereof showing receipt by DOF with blank spaces for the date and time when it was actually received as Exhibit “2-X-1;” B) The Appointment Paper of IRMA A. VILLANUEVA dated March 3, 2010 as Exhibit “2-Y” for the respondents.[54] The testimony of Ellenita G. Gatbunton, Division Chief of File Maintenance and Retrieval Division of the MRO, supports Dimaandal’s counsel’s manifestation that the transmittal of petitioners’ appointment papers is questionable. Q: In the case of Cheloy E. Velicaria-Garafil, who was appointed as State Solicitor II of the Office of the Solicitor General, was her appointment paper released through the MRO? A: No. Her appointment paper dated March 5, 2010, with its corresponding transmittal letter, was merely turned over to the MRO on May 13, 2010. The transmittal letter that was turned over to the MRO was already stamped “released” by the Office of the Executive Secretary, but the date and time as to when it was actually received were unusually left blank. Q: What is your basis? A: The transmittal letter and appointment paper turned over to the MRO. xxxx Q: In the case of Eddie U. Tamondong, who was appointed as member of the Board of Directors of Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority, was her [sic] appointment paper released through the MRO? A: No. His appointment paper dated March 1, 2010, with its corresponding transmittal letter, was merely turned over to the MRO on May 6, 2010. The transmittal letter that was turned over to the MRO was already stamped “released” by the Office of the Executive Secretary, but elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/60717 23/75