44 Here Lies Love
Westerners consider “fascinating” women leaders from underdeveloped
countries, the former is categorized as a “rock opera.” Studies about rock
often point to its capacity for subversion, and when coupled with opera
suggests the staging of a subversive performance. But what about disco?
This is Byrne’s explanation for the choice of disco: “I thought to
myself, wouldn’t it be great if—as this piece would be principally composed
of clubby dance music—one could experience it in a club setting? Could
one bring a ‘story’ and a kind of theater to the disco? Was that possible?
If so, wouldn’t that be amazing!” (2010). Another explanation that Byrne
provides is that the experience of dance music may be likened to the
experience of being intoxicated with power. In other interviews, Byrne
refers to accounts of the disco ball Imelda had installed in her New York
apartment, as well as her appearances at Studio 54.
Compared to rock, disco seems to be a more fitting genre for
capturing the frivolity and excessiveness of Imelda. The rhythm, tempo,
and beats of the songs vary, but I would say that the music evokes nostalgia
in the sense that it takes listeners back to the disco fever of the 1970s,
which coincided with the period of Imelda’s reign. The genre moreover
evokes Imelda’s overconsumption, if it is understood as a signifier of
materialism. According to music critic Richard Dyer, disco “is a riot of
consumerism, dazzling in its technology (echo chambers, double and more
tracking, electric instruments), overwhelming in its scale (banks of violins,
massed choirs, the limitless range of percussion instruments), lavishly
gaudy in the mirrors and tat of discotheques, the glitter and denim flash of
its costumes” (1979/1990, 357).
Dyer points out that disco may have subversive potential if one
recognizes the contradiction between the intense experience of disco and
the monotonous experience of everyday life outside of disco (Ibid 357358). This ironic use of the genre is what Byrne generally fails to do in his
project, which I will comment on further in the discussion of representative
songs.
A review from Filipino writer Jessica Zafra commends Byrne’s
choice of music for “Here Lies Love”:
The Imelda who emerges from Here Lies Love is not the greedy,
power-mad virago many would prefer to see, but a naive country girl
who truly believes that the story of the Philippines is her story. In her
mind she IS the Philippines. Isn’t that what dance music does? For four
minutes, it makes you believe that you are the invincible queen of the
dance floor. It’s a match (2010).