De La Cruz vs NLRC : 115527 : August 18, 1997 : J. Padilla : First Div... 8 of 8 http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/1997/aug1997/115527.htm [11] Rollo, pp. 167-178. (Private respondent adopted its comment on the petition as its memorandum, Rollo, p 179) [12] Rollo, pp. 136-145. [13] Rollo, p. 141. [14] Rollo, pp. 200-204. [15] 176 SCRA 465 (1989) at pp. 474-475. [16] Ibid. [17] Annex A, Rollo, pp. 26-29. [18] 102 SCRA 835 at p. 842, citing Madrigal v. Ogline (104 Phil. 748). Philgrecian Maritime Services v NLRC (139 SCRA 285) at p. 294. 1/24/2016 11:10 PM