M.R. Jacinto et al. / Fisheries Research 161 (2015) 174–181
179
Table 6
Vulnerability indices of tuna and sardine sectors to climate change in selected landing sites in General Santos and Zamboanga City.
Parameters
VA components
Exposure
Fishing ground
Household
Catch comparison
Age structure
Dependence on resource
Health conditions
Awareness
Sources of CC information
Strategies
Literacy
Sensitivity
Adaptive Capacity
Overall Vulnerability Index
Tuna sector in General Santos
Sardine sector in Zamboanga City
Score
Subtotal
Score
Subtotal
L
L
M
L
H
L
L
L
L
M
L
M
L
M
L
H
L
L
L
L
M
L
M
L
M
M
L
M
Legend: L = low, M = medium, H = high vulnerability.
systems or programs for climate change. These support systems
or programs usually include seminars, workshops, and training
that inform and educate people on the current issues of climate
change and how they can deal with the impacts through adaptation, risk reduction, and diversification of livelihood (e.g., Songcuan
and Santos, 2013). Data from this variable were collected from local
leaders (i.e., city or provincial agriculturist officer).
3.1.3.6. Access to information. The fisher’s ability to cope with the
disasters brought about by climate change depends on their accessibility to climate-related knowledge through different means (i.e.,
TV, radio, newspaper, internet, school, etc.).
3.1.3.7. Annual income from fishing. Livelihood income from fishing
is a common indicator that characterizes the economic profile of a
community (e.g., Muallil et al., 2011; Mamauag et al., 2013). A highaverage income generated from fishing indicates a lower capacity of
the community to adapt to climate change stressors. A community
has higher adaptive capacity if most of the livelihood income of the
people is derived from supplemental livelihoods or other sources.
3.2. Vulnerabilities of tuna and sardine sectors
Fifty local fishermen were interviewed at selected landing
sites, of which 25 were from General Santos and 25 were from
Zamboanga City. The vulnerability indices for tuna in General
Santos and sardines in Zamboanga City indicate medium overall
vulnerability (Table 6 and Fig. 3). Medium sensitivity and low adaptive capacity values (Table 6) indicate that the tuna and sardine
resources in General Santos and Zamboanga City are vulnerable
to climate change. This finding suggests that the effects of climate change vary in different areas and depend on the nature
and level of resource dependency of the community. Thus, specific
and more localized management measures or adaptive strategies should be developed for each area. The sardine sector in
Zamboanga City is more vulnerable to climate change than the
tuna sector in General Santos because of the high exposure of
the fishing grounds to localized typhoons, which makes fishing
difficult or even prohibits fishing operations. Hence, policy makers and program implementers should invest more on programs
(e.g., livelihood and climate change awareness) that reduce the
dependence of sardine fishers and other stakeholders in the sardine
sector.
Fig. 3. Vulnerability map of sardine and tuna sectors of barangay Cawit, Zamboanga City and barangay Tambler, General Santos.