Eduardo Nana, one of the complainants xxx . In the first week of February 1993, he learned from
his friend Willy Ramos xxx that his sister Elizabeth Ramos Borromeo and her husband Ernesto
Borromeo (appellant) needed workers to be sent abroad (pp. 19-21, TSN, Feb. 9, 1994). Nana
told Willy Ramos that he was interested to apply (p. 20, TSN, Feb. 9, 1994). xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx Appellant his spouse confirmed that they can help Nana go abroad but he has to pay
P3,000.00 and P12,000.00 for processing of documents (p. 21, TSN, Feb. 9, 1994). Nana agreed
to pay the price and applied for job as a factory worker which according to the couple, fetched a
salary of around $800.00 a month (pp. 22-23, TSN, ibid).
On February 22, 1993, Nana paid P3,000.00 to Elizabeth Ramos-Borromeo who then handed the
amount to appellant who then counted the money (pp. 23-24, TSN, Feb. 9, 1994). Afterwards,
she issued a receipt for the amount containing her signatures (pp. 24-25, TSN, Feb. 9, 1994; Exh.
H). Such payment was made at the house of Willy Ramos xxx
Appellant assured Nana that if he completes payment of the additional P12,000.00, Nana could
go to Taiwan (p. 25, TSN, ibid.). Accordingly, Nana made a second payment in the amount of
P12,000.00 to the Borromeo couple on March 15, 1993 (Exh. I; pp. 25-26, TSN, Feb. 9, 1994).
Subsequently, Elizabeth Ramos-Borromeo issued a receipt for said amount where she signed
both her and appellants name (pp. 23-30, TSN, Feb. 9, 1994). However, despite such payment,
Nana was unable to go abroad as appellant and his wife had promised him (p. 26, TSN, Feb. 9,
1994). xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
IV
On March 1, 1993, Lamberto Pinga met appellant xxx when he applied with him for a job in
Taiwan as factory worker (pp. 2-4, TSN, Feb. 14, 1994). Appellant told Pinga that he had to pay
the processing fee of the papers in the amount of P15,000.00 before could go to Taiwan (pp. 4-7,
TSN, Feb. 14, 1994). Pinga made a partial payment of P3,000.00 on the same day for which a
receipt in yellow pad dated March 1, 1993 was issued (pp. 4-5, TSN, Feb. 14, 1994, Exh. G).xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx He made another partial payment on March 17, 1993 jointly with Ortiz in the amount of
P10,000.00 for himself and Edwin Ortiz (or P5,000.00 for each of them) for which receipt was
issued (pp. 9-10, TSN, Feb. 14, 1994, Exh. D; D-1). At the time that he made the payments,
appellants wife and brother-in-law were also present (pp. 9-12, TSN, Feb. 14, 1994). Later,
Pinga made another payment in the amount of P1,600.00 to appellants brother-in-law William
Ramos but no receipt therefor was issued (pp. 11-12, TSN, Feb. 14, 1994).
Notwithstanding his payments, nothing happened to Pingas application. xxx