6/5/2020 E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly [18] Id. at 118-120. [19] Id. at 192-251. [20] Filed on October 17, 2012. Id. at 170-188. [21] Id. at 208-209. [22] See id. at 178-185. [23] See Position Paper for respondents filed on October 17, 2012; id. at 89-113. [24] Id. at 100. [25] Id. at 106. [26] Id. at 108. [27] Id. at 57-72. Penned by LA Lilia S. Savari. [28] Id. at 68-69. [29] Id. at 70. [30] See Notice of Appeal with Memorandum of Appeal dated December 12, 2012; id. at 300-336. [31] The NLRC case was re-docketed as NLRC LAC No. 01-000062-13. [32] CA rollo, pp. 41-56. [33] Id. at 319. [34] Id. at 49, 51-52. [35] Id. at 52-54. [36] Id. at 122-143 [37] Id. at 53-54. [38] See motion for reconsideration dated April 12, 2013; id. at 75-85. [39] Id. at 73-74. elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/61727 10/13