[4] Id. at 60-87. The Decision was penned by Associate Justice Sixto C. Marella, Jr. and concurred in by Associate Justices Mario L. Guarina III and Japar B. Dimaampao of the Sixteenth Division, Court of Appeals, Manila. [5] Id. at 89-90. The Resolution was penned by Associate Justice Sixto C. Marella, Jr. and concurred in by Associate Justices Amelita G. Tolentino and Lucenito N. Tagle of the Former Sixteenth Division, Court of Appeals, Manila. [6] Id. at 187-193. Order. [7] Id. at 183-186. [8] Id. at 148-167. [9] Id. at 191. [10] Id. at 144-147. Resolution. [11] Id. at 91-95. [12] Id. at 189-191. [13] Id. at 61-62. [14] Id. at 62. [15] Id. at 91-95. [16] Id. at 92-93. [17] Id. [18] Id. at 93. [19] Id. [20] Id. [21] Id. at 94. [22] Id. at 65-66. [23] Id. at 148-167. [24] Id. at 151. [25] Id. at 176-180. [26] Id. at 175. [27] Id. at 181-182. [28] Id. at 19-20. [29] Id. at 181 and 81. [30] Id. at 183-186. [31] Id. at 183.