Separate Concurring Opinion
20
G.R. No. 224469
The Torrens system registers and guarantees the legal rights of
private land owners. The system was devised during the 1830s by Sir
Robert Torrens who had served as commissioner of customs in South
Austria before becoming a land registrar of deeds ....
The Torrens system promotes the use of land as a marketable
commodity. Unlike customary systems, a Torrens title holder need have no
relation to the land other than what is stated in the Torrens document. A
Torrens title holder is also generally free to convey his or her rights to
anyone, regardless of whether or not they belong to the community where
the land is located or whether they intend to use the land or leave it idle. 100
Subsequently, Act No. 926, otherwise known as the Public Land Act,
was passed. It provided for the various modes as to how public lands can be
alienated either through a homestead application, sale, lease, issuance of free
patents to native settlers, creation of town sites, or for perfection of titles and
Spanish grants. In this regard, the Public Land Act recognized the natives'
rights over land that they have continuously occupied and cultivated, either
by themselves or through their ancestors:
SECTION 32. Any native of the Philippine Islands now as
occupant and cultivator of unreserved, unappropriated agricultural public
land, as defined by the Act of Congress of July first, nineteen hundred and
two, who has continuously occupied and cultivated such land, either by
himself or through his ancestors, since August first, eighteen hundred and
ninety; or who prior to August first, eighteen hundred and ninety eighty
continuously occupied and cultivated such land for three years
immediately prior to said date, and who has been continuously since July
fourth, nineteen hundred and two, until the date of the taking effect of this
Act, an occupier and cultivator of such land, shall be entitled to have a
patent issued to him without compensation for such tract of land, not
exceeding sixteen hectares, as hereinafter in this chapter provided.
In 1919, Act No. 2874 101 superseded Act No. 926. The second Public
Land Act "was more comprehensive in scope but limited the exploitation of
agricultural lands to Filipinos and Americans and citizens of other countries
which gave Filipinos the same privileges." 102
The Public Land Act was followed by Act No. 1148 or the Forest Act.
Prior to its enactment on May 7, 1904, the Organic Law of July 1, 1902
already provided, to some extent, the legal framework and procedure for the
allocation of legal rights relating to forest lands and the resources found
there. The Organic Law provided that the United States Government shall
have the power "to issue licenses to cut, harvest, or collect timber or other
100
101
102
Owen James Lynch, Jr., Invisible Peoples and a Hidden Agenda: The Origins of Contemporary
Philippine Land Laws, 63 PHIL. L. J. 249,282 (1988).
Republic Act No. 2874, sec. 128 provides:
Section 128. Act Numbered Nine hundred and twenty-six known as the "Public Land Act," and all
acts and regulations, or parts thereof, inconsistent with the provisions of this Act, are hereby repealed.
See J. Puno, Separate Opinion in Cruz v. Secretary of Natural Resources, 400 Phil. 904, 940 (2000)
[Per Curiam, En Banc].
/