ARTEMIO V. PANGANIBAN
Chief Justice
[1]
Penned by Justice Martin S. Villarama, Jr. and concurred in by Justices Angelina Sandoval-Gutierrez
(now Associate Justice of this Court) and Romeo A. Brawner (now retired).
[2]
NLRC records, p. 3.
[3]
Id., pp. 7-9.
[4]
Id., pp. 59-60, 67.
[5]
Id., pp. 58, 63.
[6]
Id., pp. 79, 111, 121 and 125, CA rollo, p. 112.
[7]
CA rollo, p. 43.
[8]
Id.
[9]
Id., p. 45.
[10]
Id., p. 50.
[11]
Id., p. 52.
[12]
Id., p. 66.
[13]
Id., p. 3.
[14]
Id., p. 117.
[15]
Id., p. 216.
[16]
356 Phil. 811 (1998).
[17]
CA rollo, p. 260.
[18]
350 Phil. 92 (1998).
[19]
CA rollo, p. 292.
[20]
Id., p. 300.
[21]
Id., p. 312.
[22]
Rollo, p. 19.
[23]
Supra, note 18.
[24]
CA rollo, p. 112.
[25]
Rollo, p. 69.
[26]
Id., p. 77.
[27]
Should be May 5, 2000, rollo, p. 17.
[28]
Reyes v. Sps. Torres, 429 Phil. 95, 101 (2002); Philippine National Bank v. Court of Appeals, 353 Phil.
473, 480 (1998); Aguilar v. Court of Appeals, 320 Phil. 456, 460 (1995).
[29]
Fulgencio v. National Labor Relations Commission, G.R. No. 141600, September 12, 2003, 411 SCRA
69, 78; Coronel v. Desierto, 448 Phil. 894, 903 (2003).
[30]
Jose v. Court of Appeals, 447 Phil. 159, 166 (2003); Buenaflor v. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 142021.
November 29, 2000, 346 SCRA 563, 567.
[31]
Tamayo v. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 147070, February 17, 2004, 423 SCRA 175, 180; Magsaysay
Lines, Inc. v. Court of Appeals, 329 Phil. 310, 323 (1996).