89
AVAILABLE MECHANISMS, EFFECTIVENESS, CSO POSITION
Table 1. Available conflict resolution mechanisms and their effectiveness
Level
Village
District
State institutions,
formal/informal mechanisms
Assessment of effectiveness
Village Government/Mechanism:
Village assembly and/or
caucuses based on local context
governance
n Depends on the position of village
District Government
n Political or conflict interest/opportunity
n Short term agenda, time consuming
n Capacity, knowledge, and awareness
District Parliament (institution,
elites/politician)
n
n
n
n
n
Police and/or Court System
n Litigation, criminal-approach (law bias, formal
government/apparatus (community vis a vis the
village government/apparatus)
n
n
n
n
National Land Agency
Political or conflict interest/opportunity
Short-term agenda
Capacity, knowledge, and awareness
Authority in execution, recommendation
Budget issue
rights)
Time consuming
Expensive
Expert witness issue
Gap between court decision and execution
n No breakthrough regulations (clear & clean
approach)
n Depends on national mechanism and decision
n Time consuming
n Limited sectoral focus/ “sectoral ego”
Province
Task Force on Conflict Resolution
n
n
n
n
Political interest/opportunity
Short term agenda/will
Capacity, knowledge and awareness
Budget issue
Provincial Government
n
n
n
n
Strong political interest/opportunity
Short term agenda/will, time consuming
Capacity, knowledge and awareness
Authority in execution (national dependency),
recommendation only
Provincial Parliament (institution,
elites/politicians)
n
n
n
n
Strong political interest/opportunity
Short term agenda/will
Capacity, knowledge and awareness
Limited authority in execution,
recommendatory
n Budget issue
Indonesia Monitoring Report of Agrarian Conflicts for 2017-2018
The table below presents the various conflict resolution mechanisms available
in the country, and assessment of the effectiveness of each.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents