REYNATO S. PUNO
Chief Justice
[1]
Penned by Associate Justice Renato C. Dacudao, with Associate Justices Lucas P. Bersamin and Vicente S.E.
Veloso, concurring; rollo, pp. 41-53.
[2]
Rollo, p. 55.
[3]
Records, p. 22.
[4]
Id.
[5]
Id. at 10.
[6]
Id. at 24.
[7]
Id. at 26.
[8]
Id. at 44.
[9]
Id. at 46.
[10]
Id. at 44.
[11]
Id. at 46.
[12]
Id. at 48.
[13]
Id. at 45.
[14]
Id. at 44.
[15]
Id. at 31.
[16]
Id.
[17]
Id. at 100-102.
[18]
Id. at 51.
[19]
Id. at 49.
[20]
Id. at 50.
[21]
Id. at 55.
[22]
Id. at 56.
[23]
Id. at 57.
[24]
Id. at 59.
[25]
Id. at 2.
[26]
Id. at 68-77.
[27]
Id. at 76-77.
[28]
G.R. No. 82248, January 30, 1992, 205 SCRA 591.
[29]
G.R. No. 82607, July 12, 1990, 187 SCRA 358.
[30]
CA rollo, p. 95.
[31]
Id. at 126-131.
[32]
Id. at 130.
[33]
Records, pp. 186-197.
[34]
Id. at 198-199.
[35]
CA rollo, pp. 2-13.
[36]
Id. at 7.
[37]
372 Phil. 9, 19 (1999).
[38]
CA rollo, pp. 199-211.
[39]
Id. at 210-211.
[40]
Id. at 212-222.
[41]
Id. at 230.
[42]
Rollo, p. 20.
[43]
376 Phil. 738, 747 (1999).
[44]
Gau Sheng Phils., Inc. v. Joaquin, G.R. No. 144665, September 8, 2004, 437 SCRA 608, 616.
[45]
NFD International Manning Agents v. National Labor Relations Commission, 348 Phil. 264, 273 (1998).