46 Here Lies Love
opens with this stanza: “We’re talking—about the whole man/In body—
in mind and in spirit/And you, give the body, what is good, good, good,
good/You make him—educated.” The song explains Imelda’s philosophy
of love and beauty, her interest in cosmology, and her infamous “Pac-man”
sketches.
Even as more songs are told from the perspective of Imelda, it is
more crucial to look into those sung by Imelda’s Other in the narrative:
Estrella Cumpas. The album’s narrative attempts to show the opposite
paths that Imelda and Estrella’s lives took. As Imelda rose to power, Estrella
plunged further into poverty, despite the promise earlier made by Imelda’s
mother that Estrella will “be taken care of.”
“Every Drop of Rain” illustrates how Estrella and Imelda lived in
poverty together, but their dreams and concerns were different to begin
with. Estrella worried about how they would survive: “When it rained we
slept on boxes/There was water all around”; Imelda was already dreaming
of a better life: “But the people in the big house/Never bothered to find
out/No clothes, no bed, no jewelry/Sometimes I had no shoes.” Two tracks
later, Estrella sings again in “How Are You?” Estrella pays a visit to Imelda
who was already living with rich Romualdez relatives in Manila. Although
the lyrics seem to cover an exchange between the two, Estrella sings the
entire upbeat song that fades away in the end, signaling that this is the last
time they will meet. This stanza hints at the inevitable parting of ways:
“And your life—is just beginning/And my life—is almost through/I’ve
given up—never finished school/There was too much—too much work to
do.”
After two tracks that feature Imelda and Ferdinand’s romance,
the wistful song “When She Passed By” portrays Estrella as an outsider to
Imelda’s new life of power. She sings about how she read about Imelda’s
marriage in the news, and that she’s happy for Imelda. The song portrays
Estrella’s refusal to accept that Imelda has forgotten her, because “letters get
lost in the mail.” The last lines of the song shows that Estrella acknowledges
Imelda’s importance in history: “Feel like I’m watching history/Living
before my eyes/Many years from now/We’ll recall just how/How she
looked when she passed by.”
It takes eight tracks after for Estrella to resurface in “Never So Big.”
Estrella’s words are confusing, as she herself still cannot accept that Imelda
has forgotten her. She asks questions like “Can I get a message through to
you?” and “Are you the girl that I once knew?” The 19th track of the album
opens Act IV (Imelda’s downfall), “Solano Avenue,” a funky soul song that
shows Estrella’s revenge. Although not integrated in the lyrics, notes on
the scene structure explain that Estrella exposed Imelda’s life of poverty in