2 CONSOL ENERGY (US), BHP BILLITON (AU), ANGLO AMERICAN (UK), RWE (DE), ENI (IT), RIO TINTO (UK), ARCH COAL (US), ANADARKO (US), OCCIDENTAL (US), LUKOIL (RU), ROSNEFT (RU), SASOL (ZA), REPSOL (ES), MARATHON (US), HESS (US), GLENCORE (CH), ALPHA NATURAL RESOURCES (US), FREEPORT MCMORAN (US) ENCANA (CA), DEVON ENERGY (US), BG GROUP (UK), WESTMORELAND MINING (US), SUNCOR (CA), KIEWIT MINING (US), NORTH AMERICAN COAL (US), RAG, (DE), LUMINANT (US), LAFARGE (FR), HOLCIM (CH), CANADIAN NATURAL RESOURCES (CA), APACHE (US), MURRAY COAL (US), UK COAL (UK), HUSKY ENERGY (CA), HEIDELBERGCEMENT (DE), CEMEX (MX), ITALCEMENTI (IT), MURPHY OIL (US), TAIHEIYO (JP), OMV GROUP (AT). Respondents. x--------------------------------------------------------------x CONSOLIDATED REPLY Petitioners, by the undersigned legal representatives, respectfully state: PREFATORY STATEMENT Hindi lang problemang pangkapaligiran ang climate change, ito rin ay isyu ng katarungang panglipunan. Pinalalala ng climate change ang paghihirap ng mga mamamayan at inilalagay sila sa lalong kapahamakan. Kaya mahalagang papanagutin ang may mga pinakamalaking responsibilidad sa paglubha ng climate change1. -Renee Karunungan, DAKILA Philippine Collective for Modern Heroism, one of petitioners 1 English translation in essence: Climate change isn’t just an environmental issue it’s also a social justice issue. It exacerbates poverty and makes people even more vulnerable to disasters. It is crucially important to us that those most responsible for making climate change worse are held to account.