{ • f)~ •. Decision t T • G.R. No.22T363 WE CONCUR: aw~ ANTONIO T. CARPIO ~~~.; l'.1ARIANO C. DEL CASTILLO Associate Justice ~AU-~~~·~ ESTELA t;fP~S-BERNABE l\1ARVIC MA'RIO VICTOR F. LEO Associate Justice ; JV'\ ~ u::~· Associate Justice Ar. u.ee cJ,epvc.je '""'"' ~'~ ~ r.., J. (pJ"'"~ + Of>'~·CY\ {Ps~l / A fRANCIS IVJARDaEZA Associate Justice t!l ANDRE Ass AiiFRIWO ~JlmffN'S. /Associa1J /J :..1stice u. REYES, JR, e Justice Gfo~a~~ ~~ PAUL. ,- RAlVlON HERNANDO Associate Justice No part Associate Justice AMY C. LAZARO-JAVIER Associate Justice -..;