14
T.A. Cinco et al. / Atmospheric Research 145–146 (2014) 12–26
combined to create significant negative impacts for a developing country with a growing population (Yumul et al., 2011,
2013).
Indeed, the Philippines has been identified as one of the
most vulnerable nations to the impacts of climate change;
a function of the density of populations living near to the
coast and in marginal upland settings and the frequency and
intensity of extreme events including tropical cyclones, associated flooding and rain triggered landslides (Yumul et al.,
2011; Yusuf and Francisco, 2009). Identifying, quantifying and
understanding the threats and associated risks are therefore of
the utmost importance for decision makers in a range of sectors
to provide accurate and timely information to those communities at risk. Recent efforts to predict the impacts of a changing
climate across a range of sectors including agriculture, have led
to the integration of climate change oriented policies and the
creation of new institutions and bodies to ensure that social
and economic interests are protected (PAGASA, 2011; Republic
of the Philippines, 2009, 2010, 2011). Such institutional tools
designed to improve the Philippines' resilience and adaptive
capacities are only effective if they are guided robust scientific
data.
3. Methods
3.1. Data gathering
The Philippines Atmospheric Geophysical Astronomical
Services Administration (PAGASA) under the Department of
Science and Technology (DOST) is responsible for managing a
countrywide network of over 50 synoptic weather stations
which have captured daily rainfall and temperature data
since the 1950s and as early as 1911 in some cases, and from
which the observed data discussed here is retrieved.
The records gathered from the selected stations have been
compiled to form a time series data set for daily near surface
temperature and precipitation. Data observed and collected
between 1951 and 2010 was used and the baseline or
reference period against which anomalies or departures from
this norm are measured is 1961 to 1990 for mean, minimum
and maximum temperatures and extreme temperature and
precipitation events.
In order for the synoptic station to be included in the
sample, certain criteria relating to the quality of the data
produced had to be met including; records were for as long
as possible including the reference period 1961–1990; less
than 20% of the daily values were missing in each year
(i.e. ≥293 days data available); the stations were of high
quality and well-maintained; and the station had been
located at a single site during the period of record. Fig. 1
shows the location of the stations from which data was
retrieved, in their topographic context. Most of the stations
are located in the coastal areas of the Philippines which is
where many of the population centres are situated. However,
two of the stations – those at Baguio and Malaybalay – are
located in upland areas of Luzon and Mindanao, respectively,
which is important to note when considering the results,
particularly for rainfall extremes. Appendix A provides
available metadata relating to the location of the stations
used in this study.
3.2. Data quality and inhomogeneities
Whilst every effort was taken to select the synoptic
weather stations with the highest quality, most complete
data, some discontinuities in the data are inevitable and were
therefore statistically treated to remove inhomogeneities
which can affect the mean climatic values and in turn the
anomalies and extremes (Manton et al., 2001). Common
causes of data discontinuities include the relocation of
synoptic stations, any change in the measurement or data
gathering techniques used as well as mechanical damage to
the station (De Lima et al., 2013; Griffiths et al., 2005; Shahid
et al., 2012). In the Philippines, there has been a rapid
increase in population since the middle of the 20th century
which has led to a commensurate increase in population
density (from 68 capita km−2 in 1950 to 303 capita km−2 in
2010) and growing urbanisation. Unfortunately, this means
that many of the stations included here are now situated in
urban locations and subject to the heat island effect, a fact
which should be considered when assessing the results.
An initial visual inspection of the complete datasets was
conducted in order to identify and eliminate any obvious
outliers which were outside three standard deviations from
the daily mean values, although this form of initial subjective
treatment may mean that some genuine trends have been
excluded. To identify and eliminate discontinuities, the data was
subsequently arranged in series, creating mean, minimum and
maximum daily temperatures and annual precipitation for
each station. This data was then subjected to a form of nearest
neighbour statistical analysis using the Multiple Analysis of
Series for Homogenization (MASH) software following Manton
et al. (2001) which compares the target station data with that
of climatically similar stations to identify significant changes
in the target station. MASH was originally developed by the
Hungarian Meteorological Service and has become widely
used as an acceptably accurate means of conducting homogeneity tests and for smoothing time series data (Lakatos et al.,
2013; Szentimrey, 2011; Zhen and Zhongwei, 2010). Once
discontinuities were identified, if they could be linked to
changes in the weather station or data management technique,
then they were excluded otherwise they were included in the
final dataset. However, overall this technique may still allow
for the inclusion of undetected inhomogeneities and this
should be considered when reviewing the results. The overall
mean annual temperature used data from all 34 synoptic
stations but for the extreme rainfall events a number of stations
were discounted on the basis that some of the daily data was
not wholly reliable.
3.3. Data analysis and trend identification
Remaining data from the identified highest quality synoptic
stations was further analysed to identify climatic trends for
both rainfall and temperature.
3.3.1. Mean temperature trends
The first step was to arrange the observed annual mean of
daily temperature for each of the selected synoptic stations
to create a time series 1951–2010. National values were
calculated by taking the arithmetic mean from all the stations
included in the study. Using this data the mean annual