Amicus Curiae Brief presented by
ClientEarth
21 November 2016
20. This provision limits the judicial function to the Supreme Court and the lower courts
established by law. In accordance with this clear constitutional separation of powers,
the powers and functions of the Commission as expressed in Article 13 do not
extend to the determination of legal rights and liabilities. The Commission has no
power to determine actual controversies between individual private parties, between
the Filipino state and its citizens, or between independent nation states.
21. The Commission’s investigatory and advisory function is clearly reflected by the
Omnibus Rules of Procedure of the Commission on Human Rights (enacted under
the power in section 18(2) of Article 8 of the Constitution) (Omnibus Rules). Section
2 of Rule 7 states that "[t]he investigative and inquiry proceedings of the CHR is factfinding in nature, and non-adversarial."
22. Furthermore, Rule 3 section 2, which describes the objectives of the Commission's
investigation and monitoring function in respect of civil and political rights restricts the
Commission's function to making findings of fact and recommendations to
government. Section 17 of Rule 4 of the Omnibus Rules also makes it clear that the
outcome of the Commission's investigation will be a final report containing those
findings of fact, and corresponding recommendations as to appropriate criminal,
administrative or civil actions to be taken by other organs of the state of the
Philippines. These provisions confirm that the Commission is not empowered to
exercise a judicial function under the Constitution of the Philippines.
3.2 Personal jurisdiction
12