'•
Decision
-3-
G.R. No. 227363
genitalia. She noticed that her genitalia was swollen. AAA then confessed to
her about the wrong done to her by appellant whom AAA referred to as
Badong or Salvador Tulagan. AAA cried hard and embraced BBB tightly.
AAA asked BBB for her help and even told her that she wanted Badong to
be put in jail.
AAA, nine (9) years old, testified that sometime in September 2011
while she was peeling com with her cousin who lived adjacent to her
grandmother's house, Tulagan approached her, spread her legs, and inserted
his finger into her private part. She said that it was painful, but Tulagan just
pretended as ifhe was just looking for something and went home.
AAA, likewise, testified that at around 11 :00 a.m. of October 8, 2011,
while she was playing with her cousin in front of Tulagan's house, he
brought her to his house and told her to keep quiet. He told her to lie down
on the floor, and removed her short pants and panties. He also undressed
himself, kissed AAA' s cheeks, and inserted his penis into her vagina. She
claimed that it was painful and that she cried because Tulagan held her
hands and pinned them with his. She did not tell anyone about the incident,
until her aunt examined her private part.
Upon genital examination by Dr. Brenda Tumacder on AAA, she
found a healed laceration at 6 o'clock position in AAA's hymen, and a
dilated or enlarged vaginal opening. She said that it is not normal for a
9-year-old child to have a dilated vaginal opening and laceration in the
hymen.
For the defense, Tulagan claimed that he did not know AAA well, but
admitted that he lived barely five (5) meters away from AAA's
grandmother's house where she lived. He added that the whole month of
September 2011, from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m., he was gathering dried banana
leaves to sell then take a rest after 1:00 p.m. at their terrace, while his mother
cut the banana leaves he gathered at the back of their kitchen. He said that he
never went to AAA's house and that he had not seen AAA during the entire
month of September 2011. Tulagan, likewise, claimed that before the alleged
incidents occurred, his mother had a misunderstanding with AAA's
grandmother, who later on started spreading rumors that he raped her
granddaughter.
After trial, the RTC found that the prosecution successfully
discharged the burden of proof in two offenses of rape against AAA. It held
that all the elements of sexual assault and statutory rape was duly
established. The trial court relied on the credible and positive declaration of
{7