Philippine Journal of Science
Vol. 145 No. 3, September 2016
higher latitudes (Cushing & Dickson 1976; Portner & Peck
2010). So far, studies on the effects of El Niño on fishes
focus mainly on small and large pelagic fishes.
The spread of warm water towards EEP deepens the
thermocline and results to reduced productivity of
upwelling. During 1972/1973 El Niño, one of the results
was the devastation of anchovy fishery in Peru, one of the
largest fishery in the world, due to reduction of nutrients
(Cushing 1981; Bakun & Broad 2003). The distribution,
spawning, and recruitment of northern anchovy off
California was also negatively affected during the
1982/1983 El Niño event (Fiedler et al. 1986). This event
also suppressed the upwelling in the ECP that resulted to
a decrease in yellowfin tuna (Thunnus albacares) catches
(Miller 2007). In 1997, the stocks of small pelagic fishes
decreased again in the EEP particularly on the anchovy
fishery (FAO 2000).
In the EWP, the spread of warm pool of water extends
the distribution of tuna species. Lehodey et al. (1997)
observed an eastward movement of the tagged skipjack
tunas released in the EWP to the ECP during the 19911992 El Niño. Although the migration of skipjack tunas
were mainly driven by temperature, the inhibition of
equatorial upwelling concurrent with the spread of
warm pool of EWP also drove these species as the water
displaced eastward (Lehodey et al. 1997; Lehodey
2001). Bigeye tuna (Thunnus obesus) also extended to
the east during El Niño years (Yukinawa, et al., 1988).
In the Philippines, tuna catch drastically decreased up to
58% particularly in regions 2 and 9 with region 2 being
unable to recover after the 1997 event (Vera & Hipolito
2006). Prolonged and recurring El Niño increases the
effort of finding suitable fishing grounds and leads to
decreased tuna harvest being landed in the Philippines.
This happened to Taiwan mackerel purse seine fishery
which experienced a sharp decrease in harvest by 47.75%
during the 1997/1998 El Niño and had estimated loss of
US $6.22 million by 1998 (Sun et al. 2006).
However, temperature alone cannot explain the abundance
and distribution of fishes but also involves their feeding
habitat. As discussed above, primary productivity in the
Philippines is increased during El Niño years in some
parts of the country. Villanoy et al. (2011) noted that
sardine fishery in Zamboanga Peninsula had the highest
landed catch during some El Niño years (2003, 2005,
2007) as compared during some non- El Niño years. El
Niño enhanced the upwelling that is beneficial to pelagic
plankton-feeding species such as sardines and supported
the municipal fishery of Zamboanga.
Although high productivity means greater food source
in relation to the amount of phytoplankton present, this
could also lead to the occurrence of blooms for some
Damatac II & Santos: Possible Effects of El Niño on
Some Philippine Marine Fisheries Resources
algal species. Algal blooms not only affect shellfishes but
may also trigger fish kills due to oxygen depletion. This
poses threat to mariculture such as farms of milkfish, the
main aquaculture product of the country. On January to
February 2002, a massive fish kill of milkfish happened
in Bolinao, Pangasinan simultaneous with the occurrence
of dinoflagellate Prorocentrum minimum bloom (Azanza
et al. 2005). Aquaculture areas like Bolinao are usually
eutrophic, such that even in the absence of El Niño the
water is already prone to algal blooms. Still, oceanographic
conditions during El Niño create favorable conditions for
algal growth and further contribute to the conditions set
up by eutrophic waters. Yin et al. (1999) revealed that El
Niño was responsible for the occurrence of several red
tides in Hong Kong from 1997 to 1998, which resulted to
an estimated loss of US $32 million from fish kills. The
conditions brought by El Niño helped in the outbreak of
red tides along the eutrophic coast of China (Yin et al.
1999). Moreover, reduced rainfall and drought caused
by El Niño do not help to replenish the aquaculture
areas with cleaner waters, thus, may further contribute to
eutrophication. Martins et al. (2001) pointed out that the
input of freshwater in a eutrophic water is a major factor
that controls the incidence of algal blooms. Therefore, El
Niño may further contribute to the induction algal bloom
in many aquaculture farms of the country.
El Niño also seems to affect the transport of larvae and
juveniles. The partitioning of NEC into Kuroshio and
Mindanao currents also influences the oceanographic
processes and determines the north-south fish differences
and larval dispersal off coast the country (Alino & Gomez
1993; Qiu & Chen 2012). One example is the Japanese eel
(Anguilla japonica), that is transported through the NEC
in the northern part of the EWP and is, thus, one of the
commodities found in Northern Luzon. Kim et al. (2007)
showed through their larval transport model that eel larvae
were transported more to the Mindanao current than the
supposed route Kuroshio Current during El Niño years.
There is no data on the eel catch in Luzon, however, time
series catch in Taiwan showed that El Niño coincides to
the years of low eel production (Han et al. 2009).
Reduced precipitation during El Niño causes relatively
higher salinity and drought in the EWP. Euryhaline species
such as most species of Tilapia (Oreochromis spp.) may
not be affected by the phenomenon but other species
strongly dependent on salinity may have negative effects
to increased salinity. Portunid crabs (Scylla serrata) are
known to be influenced by salinity changes and prefer
lower salinity (Williams & Hill 1982; Bonine et al.
2008). Meynecke et al. (2012) reported that portunid crab
production is higher during La Nina when rainfall rate is
higher. Drought, on the other hand, limits the environment
of many aquaculture farms shortening the culture periods
287