4/16/2021
E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly
the identification tag and initials seen in the handle of the black bag differed from what
was written on his identification card. He was then ordered to place this black bag at
the counter's desk and to open the same.[26]
Thereafter, Williams was taken to the Lost and Found Section where he was asked to
admit ownership of a brown bag. Pictures of him beside the brown bag were then
taken.[27] He identified himself before the NAIA personnel when he was requested to
do so. The group then asked him to do them a favor by signing a statement with the
name "Antonio Navarro" written on it. Williams claimed that when he refused to sign
the same, Captain Algenio of the Customs Police ordered his men to beat him. They
tied his legs, handcuffed him and hit him with a 3"x4" piece of wood. After this ordeal,
Williams was ordered at gunpoint to affix his signature on the black and brown bags.
His pleas for legal assistance were not heeded.[28]
Williams was subsequently taken outside the airport to an office where he met a man
who asked him if he knew the penalty for the offense of carrying prohibited drugs.
Another group of men then took him to the office of Captain Samala. The latter frisked
Williams and then took the 150 dollars and 75 pesos which were found in his pocket.
The 150 dollars were not returned to Williams but the 75 pesos were given back to him
to spend for his food. Thereafter, he was transferred to the Narcotics Command
(Narcom) and then to a hospital for check-up of the injuries which he suffered as a
result of the beatings but he was not attended to therein.[29]
Williams also testified that under duress and without the assistance of counsel, he
signed a receipt of property seized from him indicating that 63 packs of more or less
22.547 kilograms of heroin were found in one of his bags.[30]
The 63 packs which were
Williams were examined by
testified that after taking
subjecting the same to a
found in the black and brown bags allegedly owned by
PNP Crime Laboratory Forensic Chemist Noemi Austero who
representative samples from each of these packs and
qualitative examination, all 63 packs tested positive for
heroin.[31] The heroin discovered in Williams' suitcases weighed 22.547 kilograms.
As regards accused-appellant Manzanza Nzenza, Captain Algenio testified that after the
arrest of accused Williams at the Departure Area, a follow-up team[32] was formed by
NAIA District Commander, Major De la Cuesta, for the capture of another black man
who, according to Williams, was also transporting prohibited drugs.[33]
Upon orders of Major De la Cuesta, the team proceeded to the satellite area located
within the NAIA departure area where they found a black man, who was later identified
as the accused- appellant Manzanza Nzenza carrying a bag similar to that carried by
Williams. Strongly suspecting that this was the other black man to whom Williams was
referring, they asked him whether he had any checked-in luggage. He replied that he
had none.[34]
Unconvinced by Nzenza's reply, the team sought the assistance of a Philippine Airlines
https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/52099
4/15