In defense of land rights: A monitoring report on land conflicts in six Asian countries
12
This regional report provides a perspective and summary of the six country
studies and highlights key discussion points and recommendations from the
Asian regional workshop.
Concepts on land conflict
Case approach. The data indicator used in the country reports are the
“cases of land and natural resource conflict.” Conflict cases are defined as
situations wherein “two or more stakeholders perceive that their interests are
incompatible, express hostile attitudes, or … pursue their interests through
actions that damage the other parties.” Interests can differ over: (a) access
to and distribution of resources; (b) control of power and decision-making;
(c) cultural, social, and political identity; and, (d) status, particularly those
embodied in systems of government, religion, or ideology (as cited in Engel
and Korf, 2005). In all the studies, land conflicts also cover disputes over water
resources, trees, forests, and rights to natural resources.
Latent and manifest conflict. It is important to understand the context of
conflict, as well as the behavior of stakeholders – particularly how they interact
and respond as the conflict unfolds. All conflicts start as latent conflict – a
situation wherein stakeholders may be unaware, or else aware yet not taking
action on how their goals and interests are competing over control of land,
resources, and decision-making. When there is inaction or withdrawal, the
conflict remains latent. But when stakeholders contend or assert their rights or
interests, it escalates into a manifest conflict or a situation where stakeholders
take action to contend or assert their rights or interests over control of land,
resources, and decision-making.
ANGOC
In cases where conflicts are not resolved, or the outcomes from third party
facilitators are not acceptable, they can escalate into violence – a show of
force or an imposition of will on another to achieve control through destructive
means.
Forms of violence. All the cases studied had an incidence of violence that
occurred within the period covered. The most visible form of violence is
physical (i.e., killing, injury, incarceration, torture, eviction, and displacement).
However, violence can also be psychological (grave threat, verbal abuse,
harassment, defamation, discrimination), economic (denial of access to
resources, services and opportunities, subjecting people to servitude, undue
debt and exploitative conditions) and/or political (denial of participation and