15
Few of the documented cases come from judicial court files; in many countries,
restrictions are imposed against commenting on sub judice cases (or cases
under litigation). Moreover, access to court documents is often restricted or
inaccessible, and court systems often do not maintain centralized databases
with categories for land cases unless these are handled by special courts. In
Nepal, however, the Supreme Court Annual Report provides summary data on
the types of cases pending in courts.
For the Indonesian and Philippine studies, efforts were made to verify and
validate information from multiple sources. Focus group discussions and
consultation workshops were conducted in each country. In the Philippine
study, 51 collected cases were excluded from the final analysis due to missing
or inaccurate information (on stakeholders, location, inclusive dates, and
nature of the conflict).
Scope of the studies
Table 2 on page 16 shows the coverage of the data on land conflict cases per
country. All the studies are national in scope. The specific period under study
varies for each country, although all documented land conflict cases occurred
between 2012-2018, with many conflicts still ongoing.
Limitations
The studies here are not all-inclusive, as many land conflict cases go unreported.
Governments do not readily disclose reliable information about land conflicts.
Thus, any research on land conflict needs to gather information from other
sources, including media and CSOs, in order to get an idea on the real size
of the problem. However, media often focuses on events that are deemed
newsworthy, such as violence and crime, rather than on long-standing land
conflicts. CSO offices and networks in each country also have limited reach,
with the more remote and inaccessible areas least likely to be reported on.
Regional Summary: A Perspective Overview of Land Conflicts in Six Asian Countries
Primary sources consist mainly of narratives and written accounts provided by
affected communities to CSOs, specifically in the cases of KPA-Indonesia and
CSRC-Nepal – which have extensive networks and regional offices within their
countries. Secondary sources consist of written accounts, case reports and
research studies of CSOs, reports from national government agencies, and
CSO monitoring of mass media reports (online and press).