16 Accounting for Health Impacts of Climate Change
Box 3 Constraints to Identifying and Quantifying the Impacts
of Climate Change in Nepal
The data and information on climatic events and health impacts in both soft and hard forms are limited, which pose
the crucial problem and challenge for health planning in Nepal. If available, the data is either limited or generated for
specific project purposes and therefore cover limited areas. Owing to a lack of adequate information, most of the
planning and decision making is taking place on an ad-hoc basis with limited concerns to long-term outcomes. The
following basic constraints with regard to climate change events and health impacts have been identified:
• There exist limited stations for recording data on weather, hydrological, and environmental phenomena. They
now are available only for major urban areas. Rugged topography, remoteness, and drudgery of movements
have further aggravated the problems of gathering data.
• There is a lack of solid and reliable information and analysis relating climatic events and human health. As a
result, it is difficult to establish cause-and-effect relationships between them. Projecting the future impacts of
climate change on health is difficult.
• Various government ministries (health, environment, water resources, home affairs, etc.) have collected data
on climatic events and health, but there has been a lack of integration and coordination to link the data nature,
size, quality, and methods among these bodies.
The most general constraint with all these organizations is the very limited budget allocated for establishing
databases, as well as limited research activities to generate information on climate phenomena and health. Few
studies on adaptation measures for weather- and climate-related disasters have been undertaken. Climate extreme
indices and indicators for monitoring, regional climate modeling, glacier risk reduction, etc., do not provide adequate
information for climate change adaptive measures.
Source: Pradhan, B. 2010. Key Sector Analysis: Health Adaptation in Nepal. Mimeo. Kathmandu.
Quantifying the future health impacts of climate change requires a number of different steps,
each fraught with its own difficulties, uncertainty, and incomplete information. This report proposed a
methodological approach, presented in Figure 9. Without being exhaustive, these steps include:
(i)
(ii)
Selecting an emissions scenarios. The Special Report on Emissions Scenarios was prepared
by the IPCC for the Third Assessment Report (2001), on future emissions scenarios to be used
for driving global circulation models to develop climate change scenarios. There exist 4 broad
families of emissions scenarios (A1, A2, B1, and B2) with the A1 emissions scenario comprising
3 different subsets (A1F1, A1B, and A1T). These scenarios differ as to the assumptions pertaining
to economic growth, population growth, the adoption of new technologies, and the degree of
integration among nations of the world. Different emissions scenarios provide different estimates
of changes in climate, and (all other things being equal) different estimates of climate changes
will provide different estimates of the future incidence of health impacts. In a recent study of
the potential impacts of climate change in Southeast Asia, ADB (2009a) used the A1FI and B2
emissions scenarios. In terms of greenhouse gas emissions, A1F1 represents a high emissions
scenario (rapid, fossil-intensive economic growth), and B2 represents a medium-case scenario.
A World Bank study (2010) uses the A2 emissions scenario. Recent empirical evidence indicates
that actual greenhouse gas emissions tend to follow emissions levels projected by high emissions
scenarios of the A1 family.
Selecting a global climate model or general circulation model (GCMs). GCMs are computer
models used to simulate the earth’s climate systems. GCMs are the main tools used to project
future climate changes due to the continued anthropogenic inputs of greenhouse gases. The major
advantage of using GCMs as the basis for creating climate change scenarios is that they estimate
changes in climate for a large number of climate variables in a physically consistent manner such
as temperature, precipitation, pressure, wind, humidity, and solar radiation. However, (a) GCMs
typically provide projections at a scale in the order of hundreds of square kilometers, which in
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents