1/5/2021
E-Library - Information At Your Fingertips: Printer Friendly
and could not have been caused by his employment conditions. To assail the ECC's
findings and prove that the nature of her late husband's work as a teacher increased
the risk of contracting diabetes mellitus, petitioner quoted the medical opinion of Dr.
Augusto Litonjua, president of the Philippine Diabetic Association, published in the
November 1, 1985 issue of Bulletin Today, to wit:
"Dr. Augusto Litonjua, president of the Philippine Diabetic Association, also
said that other causes of diabetes are overweight, accidents, operations,
pregnancy and certain drugs.
"Speaking before the weekly 'Agham Ugnayan', Litonjua said diseases
caused either by a virus or bacteria were found to have damaged the
pancreas and caused diabetes in persons 'with a predisposition.'
"Litonjua explained that a person under stressful physical or emotional
situations secrete hormones that are 'contra-insulin' or hormones which
outweigh the effects of insulin. Insulin, a hormone that is produced by the
pancreas lowered blood sugar.
"He noted that there are more diabetes cases in urban than in a rural
setting. This discrepancy is believed to be attributed to the more
'Westernized' environment in urban areas which have more problems and
tensions x x x."[26]
The wife of the deceased argued that since the parents of her late husband were not
diabetic and that the deceased was not predisposed to the ailment by reason of obesity
or old age, it would be more fair to conclude that his contracting diabetes mellitus was
increased by the nature of his work. This Court found merit in her contention and held
that:
Prisco Millora began work as a public school teacher when he was twentyone [21] years old. Although not predisposed to diabetes mellitus by reason
of old age, obesity or heredity, he became diabetic after eight [ 8] years in
said employment. As a classroom teacher, his work was not confined to the
regular eight-to-five schedule, but stretched into the long hours of the night
preparing lesson plans and instructional materials. Aside from this, he was
actively involved in the school's developmental projects. To our mind, such
work situation could reasonably be described as physically and emotionally
stressful, a situation cited by Dr. Litonjua as producing hormones which are
'contra-insulin' in their effects and which satisfies the evaluation made by
respondent Commission of the endocrinal etiology of diabetes mellitus.[27]
In this case, to prove that his work conditions caused or at least increased the risk of
contracting the disease, Apolinario showed that part of his duties as an Ordinary
Seaman in MV Algosaibi 42 involved strenuous workload such as assist in the handling
and operation of all deck gear such as topping, cradling and housing of booms; aid the
carpenter in the repair work when requested; scale and chip paint, handle lines in the
mooring of the ship, assist in the actual tying up and letting go of the vessel and stand
as a lookout in the vessel. Apolinario further stated that while inside the vessel for
several months, he was exposed to physical and psychological stress due to rush jobs,
https://elibrary.judiciary.gov.ph/thebookshelf/showdocsfriendly/1/65782
6/14