As early as 27 June 2006, respondents’ designated physicians have declared that
complainant’s condition does not appear to be work-related. With this
declaration, respondents are bound to deny complainant’s claim for disability
benefits. He cannot therefore be faulted for filing the instant case in October
2006 without waiting for the evaluation of his disability impediment by the
company designated doctors. Moreover, the 120 days period lapsed without the
latter having declared the degree of complainant’s disability, if any.
Complainant is thus considered to be totally and permanently disabled as he is no
longer capable of earning wages in the same kind of work, or work of similar
nature that he was trained for or accustomed to perform. He is now incapacitated
to work, hence, his earning capacity is impaired. Jurisprudence has declared that
disability should not be understood more on its medical significance but on loss
of earning capacity.
With the foregoing, complainant is awarded total and permanent disability
benefits in the amount of US$ 60,000.00 or its equivalent in Philippine Currency
at the time of payment.
Complainant cannot however be awarded his claim for medical and
hospitalization expenses. He did not anymore pursue this charge in his pleadings,
hence, the same remained unsubstantiated. The same holds true with his claim
for moral and exemplary damages. Complainant failed to prove bad faith or
malice on respondents’ part in denying his claims.
Complainant is entitled to attorney’s fees as he sought the assistance of his
counsel in pursuing his claims against respondents for his total and permanent
disability benefits. He is thus awarded an equivalent of ten percent (10%) of his
total claims as and by way of attorney’s fees.
WHEREFORE, in view of the foregoing, respondents Tara Trading
Shipmanagement, Inc. and/or Shinline SDN. BHD, are hereby ordered to pay
complainant Edgardo M. Panganiban his total and permanent disability benefit
in the amount of US$60,000.00 plus US$6,000.00 attorney’s fees, in Philippine
Currency, at the prevailing rate of exchange at the time of payment.