PART II : Sustainable Development and Indigenous Women
A. Article 4 : Temporary Special Measure
The State report mentions its programs on poverty alleviation, education,
livelihoods and health purportedly to improve the social safety nets and
protection in compliance to its commitments to the MDGs (paras 105-109) . The
4Ps, has now a Modified Conditional Cash Transfer (MCCT) program which has
a specific programme for home street families and indigenous peoples in
geographically-isolated and disadvantaged areas (MCCT-IPs in GIDA).
While there is a lot of reservations on the dole-out nature of this program
financed through loans, it is a welcome progress in an attempt to
comprehensively address women and girls’ marginalization. It should, however,
be noted that basic social services are priority obligations of states. On the
surface, the program has set out with a noble intent and seemingly promising
benefits according to reports. Experiences shared by indigenous women
beneficiaries, however, point to flaws which could instead compromise the intent
of empowering indigenous beneficiaries more than advancing their status. The
conditional and dole-out manner adopted by the program, for example, has
undermined community solidarity and cohesion strongly reinforced by the
common value and practice of reciprocal labor.
Among other issues, program procedures have become burdensome for
indigenous beneficiaries. The distance between indigenous communities and
pay-out centers coupled with the lack of infrastructure and services to ease
travel, among others, has precipitated domestic and gender violence.
The project documented two cases of indigenous women CCT beneficiaries
who suffered from gender-based violence, one resulting to homicide. In one of
this, a beneficiary, coming home late from the pay-out center, was almost raped
by her neighbor. The other was killed by the husband in a heated argument
after she came home late from the town center where she was interviewed for
the CCT. Local officials thought her children would be included as beneficiaries
after her death and the subsequent suicide of her husband. They were not,
however, included among the beneficiaries and are now separately living with
their relatives.
Recent stories from women beneficiaries include delayed payments of benefits
and entrusting ATM cards to enterprising lenders for loans acquired for basic
needs.
15